How to turn a competitor’s ad structure into new ad concepts (without copying the ad)
This is the fourth article in a series. Part 1: How to analyze 1,000+ competitor ads with AI. Part 2: How to stress-test AI competitor ad research before briefing your next ads. Part 3: How to break down competitor video ads beat by beat.
You have broken a set of competitor ads into beats and found the structure they share. The tempting next move is to remake the best one with your logo on it.
That gives you a weaker copy of an ad your audience may already have seen, built around a product that is not yours. This article shows what to do instead: keep the job each beat does, and rebuild everything else from your own product and audience.
Here is what the third step gives you:
You break the ads down beat by beat
Eight beats shared by three ads from one checked cluster, shown here in one of them. How to break down competitor video ads beat by beat
This article covers step 4: turning that structure into concepts for your own product. If you have a structure from your own research, use that instead.
What can you reuse from a competitor’s ad, and what can’t you?
You can reuse the job each beat does. You cannot reuse the scenes, characters or product moments that do that job in the original.
In the three ads we broke down, two connections between the beats did most of the work:
-
The product demonstration prepares the later proof. The person practises the thing they later do.
-
The ending answers the opening. The payoff reverses the specific restriction from the first scene.
Those two connections are the part worth carrying over. They are also the part a surface copy tends to lose.
What could stay the same, and what could change
| Part of the ad | What could stay the same | What could change |
|---|---|---|
| The opening | One specific situation where the person is held back, with a cost the viewer can see. A few coins in a palm does more than a sad expression. | The situation itself. The source ads are about skilled workers held back at work by English. That reflects that app’s audience. Yours needs its own evidence. |
| The help | Help arrives through a relationship. A daughter or a coworker is already using the product. | The objection. Fear of mistakes and the cost of classes belong to language learning. Your category has its own hesitations. |
| The product use | What the product does on screen is the reason the later scene goes differently. | The product’s role. A speaking tutor can rehearse the exact sentence someone uses later. Many products cannot do anything like that, so beats 5 and 6 need rethinking. |
| The ending | It returns to the opening, so the viewer can compare the two scenes without being told what changed. | The payoff. Tips and a new role fit a language barrier at work. Yours has to be something your product can plausibly contribute to. |
| The whole ad | The order of the functions: barrier, cost, help, hesitation, product use, change, recognition, action. | The characters, setting and lines. All of them. |
What does copying the surface of a competitor’s ad look like?
A surface copy keeps the scenes and swaps the product. It looks like the original and loses the connections that made the original work.
Same bakery, different logo
Suppose you market a sleep app and you admire the bakery ad. The lazy version writes itself:
Rosa has baked for twelve years. Exhausted, she gets a customer’s order wrong and the chef sends her back to the ovens. That night her daughter shows her a sleep app. She listens to a wind-down session. The next morning the same customers return, she gets the order right, and the chef gives her the front counter.
Every beat is present. Here is what went wrong:
| Beat | In the surface copy | What goes wrong |
|---|---|---|
| Opening barrier | A tired baker gets an order wrong. | The situation is borrowed. Nothing shows that your customers experience poor sleep as losing a counter job. |
| Product use | She listens to a wind-down session. | Listening to audio does not rehearse taking an order. The product no longer prepares the proof. |
| Demonstrated change | She gets the order right the next morning. | The ad now has to assert “sleep better, perform better at work” instead of showing it. |
| Recognition | The chef gives her the front counter. | A promotion after one night is a result the product cannot stand behind. |
Anyone who has seen the original will also recognize it. You have spent a production budget on a weaker version of a competitor’s ad.
Disguising the bakery does not fix this. Go back to the functions and rebuild each one from your own product and audience.
What prompt turns a beat structure into a new ad concept?
Give the AI three things: the structure with the job of each beat, what your product actually does, and the audience situation with the evidence behind it. Then ask it to work out the two connections before it writes a single scene.
Give the agent this brief
Replace the bracketed parts with your own structure, product and audience.
I want to develop new ad concepts from a story structure we found in competitor ads. Here is the structure, with the job each beat does and the two connections that make it work: [paste the beat table and the connections]. Treat it as a sequence of functions. Do not reuse the settings, characters, dialogue or product moments of the source ads. For reference, the source ads were:
.Here is our product and what it actually does, as a user experiences it: [features]. Here is what it does not do: [limits]. In the product-use beat, show only what is on the first list.
Here is the audience situation we want to write for, and the evidence behind it: [situation, with quotes from reviews, interviews, survey answers or support conversations]. If the evidence is thin, say so and treat the situation as an assumption.
Before you write any scenes, answer two questions. What can the person be shown doing with the product that makes a later scene go differently? What specific restriction in the opening can the ending reverse? If the product cannot directly cause the later change, say so. Then propose how the product-use and payoff beats should be rebuilt, rather than asserting a result.
Then write [two or three] concepts, each in a different situation, not variations of one. Give each a working title and a table with one row per beat: the story function, and what we see and hear. Write dialogue the way people speak. Mark any figure, price or on-screen wording you invent as a placeholder.
After each table, explain in two sentences how the product use prepares the payoff and how the ending answers the opening. List every assumption about the audience or the product that we need to check before production. Flag any result the product cannot promise.
Save the concepts in [folder on my computer].
The list of what the product does not do matters. Without it, a model will give the product whatever ability the story needs. A sleep app ends up “training” someone for a presentation because the structure had a rehearsal in that slot.
The two questions before any scenes matter too. They make the model settle the connections first. If it starts with scenes, you tend to get all eight beats in the right order and a product moment that has nothing to do with the ending.
Asking for different situations gives you a real choice. Three variations of one scene tell you about casting and setting. Three situations tell you which problem your audience recognizes.
What to check in the output
-
Product use: does that beat show something the product actually does?
-
The link to the payoff: could you remove the product and still reach the ending? If so, the product use is not preparing the proof.
-
The ending: does it return to the opening situation, so the viewer can compare the two?
-
Borrowed material: has any setting, character or line from the source ads slipped in?
-
The payoff: is it a change you can stand behind, or a result you cannot promise?
Expect to send it back at least once. The first draft usually keeps the order of the beats and loses one of the two connections.
The two examples below show what a finished concept looks like. The first is for a product that works like the source product. The second is for one that does not.
Example 1: a language app ad built on the same structure
When your product works the same way as the source product, the link between practice and proof survives. What changes is the situation.
Here the assumed product offers spoken role-play, correction and another chance to answer. We move from a workplace to a school meeting. A parent wants to speak for his child. The payoff shifts from income and role to taking part in his son’s schooling.
This is an original, fictional example. The audience situation and product capabilities are assumptions to validate before production.
The script: “The question he never asked”
| Story function | What we see and hear |
|---|---|
| Opening barrier | Martin’s notebook contains questions from years of school meetings, with no answers beside them. On-screen: “Four years of school meetings. The questions always came home with him.” At the next meeting he starts, “Why he… why he is…” The teacher waits. His son fills the silence: “No. Thank you.” Martin closes the notebook. |
| Concrete cost | His son points to an underlined question. “You wanted to ask about that?” Martin says, “I know you’ve gone quiet in class. I wanted to understand why.” The question remains unanswered. |
| Help | Martin tells his sister, “I understand what she says. Then it’s my turn and I lose the words.” She opens a school-meeting role-play in the app. |
| Hesitation | “I don’t need another lesson about apples and trains.” His sister replies, “Then practise the question you wanted to ask.” |
| Relevant practice | The tutor asks whether he has questions about his son. Martin says, “Why he is so quiet in class?” The app corrects the word order. He tries again, then rehearses follow-up questions over later sessions. |
| Demonstrated change | At a later meeting, Martin asks, “Why is he so quiet in class?” The teacher explains that his son waits for others to answer. Martin follows up: “Could we find a way to help him join in?” |
| Recognition | In the corridor, Martin writes an answer in the notebook. His son says, “You asked her.” They read the answer together. |
| Next action | “Practise the conversation you want to have.” Show the product flow: choose a situation, speak, receive a correction, try again. “Start your first conversation.” |
Why the notebook works
The notebook makes the change visible. At the beginning it holds questions Martin cannot ask. At the end it holds an answer because he took part.
The app addresses his speaking barrier. The child’s situation remains a conversation for the parent and teacher. The ad does not claim the app fixes it.
Example 2: adapting the structure for a sleep app
When your product works differently, the structure still helps, but the middle of the story has to be rebuilt. This is the more common case.
Why the product’s role has to change
Guided wind-down audio can support a routine. It does not teach a response that someone later performs.
That changes two beats:
-
Beat 5 becomes a relevant routine, not a rehearsal.
-
Beat 6 cannot be a performance that proves a skill. It becomes a return to an unfinished moment.
We keep the return to the opening situation, here an unfinished family moment. We also keep the routine honest: some nights she is still awake when the audio ends.
This is a hypothetical sleep app. The audience situation and product capabilities are assumptions to validate before production.
The script: “The last page”
| Story function | What we see and hear |
|---|---|
| Opening barrier | Leena opens her daughter’s book at the same bookmark on different evenings. “We’re still here?” her daughter asks. Leena loses her place and rubs her eyes. “Tomorrow. I promise.” |
| Concrete cost | Later, Leena lies awake, checking tomorrow’s calendar. At breakfast the bookmark has not moved. Her daughter says, “I kept the last page for you.” |
| Help | That evening her partner notices her checking the clock. “Now I’m counting how little sleep I’m going to get,” Leena says. Her partner offers the guided wind-down they have been using. |
| Hesitation | “Another thing on my phone?” “Just the audio. You can put the screen away.” |
| Relevant routine | She chooses a short session and puts the screen away. A thought interrupts; she returns to the voice. Across later nights she repeats the routine. Some nights she is still awake when the audio ends. “I stopped making bedtime another thing I had to get right.” |
| Demonstrated change | On a later evening she returns to the book. This time the scene stays. She reads the character’s ridiculous voice, her daughter laughs, and they reach the last page. |
| Recognition | “Again?” her daughter asks. Leena turns back to the beginning. The bookmark lies beside them. |
| Next action | “Make room to wind down.” Show choosing guided audio, putting the screen away and listening. “Try a guided wind-down.” |
How the two new concepts compare with the source ad
All three stories follow the same eight functions. Only the first two can link product use directly to the proof.
| Story function | Source ad: the bakery | Example 1: language app | Example 2: sleep app |
|---|---|---|---|
| Opening barrier | Freezes on a customer’s order. | Cannot finish his question at a school meeting. | Too tired to finish her daughter’s book. |
| Concrete cost | Sent back to the ovens; a few coins. | His question about his son stays unanswered. | The bookmark has not moved. “I kept the last page for you.” |
| Help | Her daughter uses the tutor. | His sister opens a role-play. | Her partner offers the wind-down audio. |
| Hesitation | “What if I get it wrong?” | “Another lesson about apples and trains.” | “Another thing on my phone?” |
| Product use | Practises the same order and is corrected. | Practises the same question and is corrected. | Repeats a routine. Some nights she is still awake. |
| Demonstrated change | The same customers return; she takes the order. | He asks the question and follows up. | She stays with the book to the last page. |
| Recognition | Customers defend her; the counter is hers. | “You asked her.” | “Again?” |
| Next action | Download request after the change. | “Start your first conversation.” | “Try a guided wind-down.” |
What carried across and what changed
What carried across: a repeated restriction, a personal cost, credible help, hesitation, product use and a return to the opening situation.
What changed: the language concept links rehearsed speech to a later conversation. The sleep concept proposes a routine and a relationship payoff. That second connection needs its own audience and product evidence. Neither story is a promised result.
What to validate before you produce the concept
Validate two things before spending production budget: that the situation is real for your audience, and that every product moment is true.
Audience situation
The situation in the script is an assumption until your own evidence supports it. Martin and Leena are invented. A competitor’s ad tells you what that competitor chose to show, not what your customers feel.
Look for the situation in sources you already have:
-
app store and product reviews
-
customer interviews and survey answers
-
support conversations
-
comments on your own ads
If the situation does not appear in your customers’ words, change it before you write dialogue around it.
Product claim
-
Every product moment exists. The role-play, the correction, the guided audio: each one is in the product today, as shown.
-
The payoff is a story, not a guarantee. The sleep script deliberately includes nights when she is still awake.
-
The claims have an owner. Whoever signs off claims in your category reviews the script before production, especially in health, sleep and finance.
What to do with the concept once it is written
You now have a creative choice you can explain. You started from a structure connected to source scenes. You kept the functions and the two connections, rebuilt the situation and the product’s role, and listed the assumptions to check.
That gives your team something specific to test, and a reason for each choice if the test surprises you. The concept is still a hypothesis. Its performance is for the test to show.
The next article in this series shows how to check the situation against what your customers say: How to turn customer reviews into a creative strategy for your ads.
Published